By Madyson Muresan
Arts & Culture Editor

In times such as these, we all have to make choices. Some of which we can be proud of and some are only whispered behind closed doors. Think back to when you were 17 and thought you knew who you wanted to be and what to become. Did you really know anything at all?

From addiction, depression, loss and failure, these themes in Clackamas Community College theater department’s spring musical touch each and every one of our lives and contribute to the human experience. 

Plans don’t work out and what do you do when they don’t? How do you move on from such utter failure? What is left when all your dreams and ideals are crushed? We must all answer these questions in time. 

Johnny sings alongside the supporting cast and ensemble. Photos by Carlos Rodriguez-Picazo

Green Day’s musical, “American Idiot,” is based off their Grammy award-winning album by the same name. It follows the lives of three friends as they become dissatisfied with the mediocrity of their suburban life. As they all move to The City, their lives lose the mediocrity they loathed, but gain complexity they may not be ready for. 

The first of the friends is Johnny, played by Ashton Carter, the teenager in the song “Jesus of Suburbia” by Green Day who drowns his angst and rage with soda and anti-anxiety medication. He is a spiteful teen giving the middle finger to his environment, whether that be the suburban community he lives in or his mom and step-dad that he lives with. The mental image of an early 2000s punk shines through him with his anti-government, anti-capitalism and anti-surburbia rhetoric which Green Day embodies. He has the chance to escape it all with three bus tickets for his friends and him to The City.

From left to right: Johnny, Will and Heather laugh with each other over a couple of beers. 

Then there is Will, played by Brodie O’Neill, featured alongside his girlfriend, Heather, played by Brie Nizic, with whom he has a loving relationship. He seems at first like a comedic relief character, but that perception quickly changes once his plans don’t work out quite how he wanted. After being presented with the tickets to The City, Heather tells him that she is pregnant, seemingly leading to him rejecting the ticket in favor of staying behind in Suburbia with Heather and their baby. 

The third friend is Tunny, played by Em Instenes, another disaffected teenager who takes-up Johnny’s offer of going to The City. While in The City, Tunny struggles to adjust to the new environment when he stumbles across “The Favorite Son,” the ideal all-American, ripped soldier-boy. Tunny’s glorification of “The Favorite Son” leads him to believe he must join the military which he soon does, abandoning all prior beliefs against militarism.

St. Jimmy looms over Johnny as he struggles with his drug addiction while members of St. Jimmy’s posse encourage him to continue his habits. 

The rest of the musical jumps between the three friends’ lives. Left alone in The City, Johnny meets Whatshername played by Bailey Fronk, a like-minded girl who Johnny pursues and begins a relationship with. His plans take a turn for the worse with the appearance of St. Jimmy, played by Emily Sutliff, Johnny’s drug dealer and alter-ego who embodies everything Johnny wants to be, coupled with his self-distructive tendencies. 

Will becomes neglectful towards his family and drowns his sorrows in drugs and alcohol. Heather, fed up with his absence and alcoholism, decides to leave him with their baby. She soon moves on with a new rock-n-roll boyfriend, leaving Will to struggle alone.

Tunny is deployed to a war zone where he receives a major injury to his leg. After being taken to a combat hospital, Tunny laments his life before meeting the Extraordinary Girl, played by Jessica Hansen, a nurse in the hospital that soon kindles a romance with Tunny. After losing his leg, Tunny learns to continue on with the support of his girlfriend. 

Extraordinary Girl doing a scale on Tunny’s gurney while cradling Tunny’s face in the combat hospital.

The musical numbers are all songs by Green Day and the musical is dubbed a rock-opera for that very reason. Upstage, behind the fence-lined set, is a live band who rocks out behind the actors and adds a fun element to the show. The main cast is joined by an ensemble of 11, supporting the rough and boisterous vocals as many songs involve shouting and overlapping harmonies. All songs are sung live by the cast. The band did a great job at making the songs sound like Green Day while it is understandable that the vocals didn’t quite match the professional ones of Green Day. 

The difference between the two actors of Johnny and St. Jimmy is stark and while it’s meant to be Tyler Durden-esque, there is definitely an unintentional divide also. Carter’s portrayal of Johnny can be explained as inserting himself into the role. 

His overdone facial emotes and inauthentic mannerisms that don’t align with the character give away that he is more so playing dress-up and less acting. 

In scenes with Johnny and St. Jimmy, this shortcoming becomes even more evident as Sutliff conveys the arrogance, stubbornness and apathy of the character convincingly with their chin turned-up and a strong gait to assert dominance. 

The acting seems effortless and believable, making the character an interesting case-study and enjoyable watch. 

Besides the acting inadequacy, the show was entertaining with bits of humor sprinkled throughout and engrossing musical numbers with use of fog machines and well-known rock classics. With most of the plot told through song storytelling, it made it a fun challenge to understand the inner feelings of the characters without it being spelt out for you. 

“American Idiot” runs May 21-31, Thursdays and Fridays at 7:30 p.m., Saturdays and Sundays at 2:30 p.m., in the Niemeyer Osterman Theatre at the Oregon City Campus. Tickets are free for all students. 

There is an opening night reception on May 21 at 6:30 p.m. in the Niemeyer Lobby, featuring music by Toyko Joe and light refreshments. Those who attend the opening night reception will be entered into a drawing to win Green Day merchandise. 

Avatar photo

Madyson Muresan

Madyson Muresan is a Co-Editor-in-Chief for The Clackamas Print. She is studying for a transfer degree to Portland State for marketing.

4 Comments

  1. Em Instenes on May 24, 2026 at 10:55 pm

    Hello Madyson!

    My name is Em Instenes. I played Tunny in this production of American Idiot. I have been in other productions that you have reviewed for, such as Airness.

    I respect the goal of wanting to offer your genuine opinion and criticism, which I believe everyone has the right to. If you had criticism of the show, you are absolutely entitled to what you believe. You don’t have to like what Ashton Carter did as Johnny and can believe what you have said in this article.

    The job of being a reviewer, especially for a popular local website such as the Clackamas Print, is toeing the line between giving constructive criticism and being outright mean to someone you don’t really know. There is a difference between the thoughts in our head, and the things we publish for people to read and take as genuine criticism.

    If you were genuinely trying to say something helpful, you could have been more objective.

    You wrote, “His overdone facial emotes and inauthentic mannerisms that don’t align with the character give away that he is more so playing dress-up and less acting.”. You could have said a plethora of other things, such as that you didn’t like his choices with the role. You could have offered suggestions to help potentially improve if you believe improvement is needed. But you chose to write specific harsh words for a website that many people get informed by. You wrote your personal opinion, framing it as constructive, when you’re slandering a person’s acting ability.

    The next time you potentially review for a production, I sincerely hope you have gotten theatre experience yourself before you adequately judge someone else’s acting. If you truly have, I’m surprised you would be any bit as harsh as you’re being in this article. Performing is hard. Singing can be harder. Ashton, who is singing and acting for 90 minutes straight as the lead in a rock opera musical, is completing an insane feat. Whether you believe he didn’t do what was right for the character, it should be acknowledged that he is an incredible performer that is giving his all every single night.

    If you are someone interested in watching the show reading this comment, I heavily encourage you to see the show for the rest of the cast and how much work everyone, especially Ashton Carter, has put into this for several months. We have one more weekend left.

    Madyson, I hope you reconsider how you write your articles going forward and apologize to Ashton when you see him on campus.



  2. Logan Reichert on June 1, 2026 at 3:19 pm

    Hello! I’ll prefice this comment by saying I’m a part of the CCC Theatre Community and was not in American Idiot but did go to see it three times. You wrote an article about our show last term, Witch, that I thought was a much better representation and advertisment of our department and the shows that we put on. Your previous article regarding us was clearly done with the purpose of bringing up the show, actors and department as well as getting anybody who wasn’t familiar with it excited and interested in seeing it.

    This article felt like it wasn’t given the same gentle care that the aforementioned article had. For the most part the article seems to simply summarize the story and state who had played each role with very little appreciation to how they brought it to life through specific choices. The only point where attention was taken towards specific actor choices was towards the end where you gave unwanted, snide criticisms towards Ashton Carter’s portrayal of Johnny. In the same same section you also used your criticisms of Ashton to bring up and compliment Emily Sutliff’s performance, which could have been done without tearing down Ashton’s performance.

    While I don’t think that the comments towards Ashton were done in mean spirit, tearing down the lead performer in an article meant to advertise our show as well as singling out a student who is just doing their best feels unprofessional and completely unnecessary. In the future I would hope that any criticism given is not only productive but also not targetted at a single actor and that any compliments given aren’t delivered at the expense of any other performers.



  3. Eva King on June 1, 2026 at 6:37 pm

    Hey, I’m Eva King. I was a former Arts & Culture editor for the Clackamas Print from around 2023-2025. Most of my articles covered theater performances. I’ve noticed a lot of reaction to this article so I thought I would share my opinion on it.

    I would be devastated if I was the actor you called out in this article. I’ve covered things that I did not particularly enjoy myself. For an example of this, you can see my opinion piece on 2024’s “Fire Season”. I have never found myself using language like overdone, inauthentic, or inadequacy to describe another person’s passion. When writing an opinion piece you have to tell your truth while still being polite. You don’t have to lie and say it was amazing, but to specifically call out one actor’s performance and compare his “shortcoming” to his costars acting is disrespectful. As Em Instenes said in their comment, performing a full show with songs isn’t an easy feat. This is also community college theater, and perfection shouldn’t be expected.

    I think there’s a few ways this article could’ve been handled with more care. If you found yourself having questions about the actors performance, you could have arranged an interview and asked about his inspirations for acting and gotten better insight on him as a person. You could’ve just said you were disappointed with some acting choices from the cast. As I said before, you have to balance being truthful with being polite.



  4. Tegan Richards on June 2, 2026 at 2:51 pm

    Hello! I’m Tegan. I am the Artist in Residence in the theatre department at CCC. I was also fortunate enough to participate in American Idiot this term in the ensemble.

    My main goal when offering criticism to students is to find a way to lift them up so they WANT to improve their work, all while still offering feedback.

    I understand that the woman who wrote this article is also a student. You write articles and rely on criticism from your advisors to improve. It’s the same with actors, in a way. The actor puts on a performance and relies on their director to improve.

    Take a moment to imagine what it would be like if you were in your first year of college, fresh out of high school, and looking to carry on your passion of writing. Your professor gave you a huge opportunity to write about something important to the school and is putting a lot of trust in you. You spend months working on it and you finally decide to share it with everyone.

    A week after you release it, somebody with a lot of reach posts on social media about how your style of writing was bad and made no sense, when they didn’t even bother to research the topic you wrote about to give proper criticism.

    To rub salt in the wound, the person also praised one of your classmates, saying that their writing made yours look even worse.

    Would you want to write again? I wouldn’t. I’d feel embarrassed, ashamed, and wonder why I tried in the first place. I’d avoid the classmate I was compared to and probably avoid the professor who gave me the assignment to start with. I know it’s the classic “How would you feel if this happened to you?”, but I feel it is necessary to bring up.

    I was in American Idiot and I have a list of criticisms about the musical itself/the way we decided to adapt the original musical. In fact, after watching, you ended up asking the director about plot points you didn’t understand. That would have made a great criticism! “Plot points were sometimes not easy to follow.”

    I know you are not a professor so it is not your job to uplift students, but surely supporting a first year fellow student is something most people want to do.

    And, believe me, I am all for freedom of the press. I am for free speech. But shouldn’t harsh free speech be reserved for people who deserve it – people who need to be held accountable? You could even be harsh towards the millionaires that created the musical. I just do not understand why you decided to use your power of the press to go after one child.

    Whether all this stemmed from a bad mood or political biases, I don’t know. I hope in the future we receive criticism from The Clackamas Print that is more helpful and knowledgeable. That way, we can build a better department to uplift the school and community.



Archives